A 1926 postcard in the Anna Maria Island Historical Society's collection shows a small wooden cottage standing on pilings over the water beside the City Pier. A second building, Lotus Cottage, sits just behind it. The cottage in front is Belle Haven. Today it sits on dry ground at 402 Pine Ave., raised up next to a concrete-block museum that started life as an icehouse.
Almost nothing on that lot was built for the use it has now. The cottage came from the bay. The museum was built to store ice. The old City Jail was put up in 1927 to hold rowdy patrons and was damaged by fire in the 1940s. The whole site is a record of the times the island chose to keep something it could easily have lost. Most of it costs nothing to see, and two pieces are open from dawn to dusk.
How a cottage built over the water ended up on Pine Avenue
The Anna Maria Island Sun's account of Belle Haven's reopening retells the cottage's history from the sign near its entrance. Here is the order of events:
- In the 1920s, Belle Haven was built above the water next to the City Pier.
- A large storm washed it into Tampa Bay.
- Island resident Lyman Christy bought the displaced cottage and hired a salvage crew. They recovered it with a barge and moved it to his property on Palmetto Avenue.
- Over the years it gained a sleeping porch, a kitchen, a bathroom and plumbing. It was the Christy family home for more than 50 years and a rental cottage for another 25.
- In 2000 it was slated for demolition. The Historical Society led the effort to move it, and on Nov. 27, 2001, it arrived at the museum property.
A storm carried the building off, a barge brought it back, and a planned demolition led to its last move. Each time, someone decided the cottage was worth the trouble.
The rooms show what a family's lifetime in it looked like. The Sun lists a wood-burning stove that the Island Players borrowed for their production of "Janus," and a 1930s table setting with hand-painted Chinese dishware. In the single bedroom are a wedding dress worn by four generations of brides from one family and Lyman Christy's travel trunk, which has been with the cottage for more than 75 years.
Helene reached the floorboards, and the island paid to replace them
The cottage stands higher off the ground than the museum next to it, and in 2024 the height made a difference. During Hurricane Helene, an inch and a half to two inches of floodwater seeped into Belle Haven, enough that the floors had to be redone. Milton took a screen door, and that was the only other damage.
The ground-level museum fared worse. According to the Sun's Heritage Day report, Helene's surge destroyed the display cases, though most artifacts were saved. Floors were replaced and water-damaged walls repaired, but some documents and newspaper archives were damaged, lost or misplaced. The City of Anna Maria paid for the repairs and renovations. The museum held a soft reopening on Feb. 25, 2025, the Sun reported at the time, and the Heritage Day report puts the official reopening at March 25, 2025. In the earlier article, docent David Haddox said the museum had lost some things but saved many one-of-a-kind pieces.
When the galleries reopened, the displays had been rearranged around what survived: vintage clothing, military uniforms, maps, illustrations and antique fishing gear. There was also a new piece, a digital collage of the damage from Helene and Milton.
Belle Haven was the last piece to come back. The Anna Maria Island Chamber of Commerce held a ribbon-cutting on Oct. 1, 2025, and dozens of people came that Wednesday evening. Carolyn Orshak is a docent, and the society's board page lists her as president. She described the evening to the Sun this way:
"We are celebrating our last hurdle in the museum being back to normal. It's a celebration of resiliency."
The board page describes a museum run largely by volunteers, with board members handling collections, public events, gift-shop stock, fundraising, docent training and marketing. The recovery followed the same pattern as the cottage's first rescue: people from the island deciding the place was worth saving and doing the work themselves.
What's on the lot, and when you can walk in
The grounds have four parts, and each one gets a different kind of visit. Here is how they compare, based on the Historical Society's visitor page and the Chamber's island history:
| Piece | What it was | How to see it |
|---|---|---|
| Museum and gift shop | A concrete-block icehouse | Free during open hours, donations welcome, docent-led gallery tours on request |
| Belle Haven Cottage | A 1920s cottage built over the water by the City Pier | Docent-guided tour only |
| Old City Jail | An open-air cell used from 1927 to the late 1940s | Outdoors, dawn to dusk |
| Mangrove Walk | A short path through a native-plant garden | Outdoors, dawn to dusk, ending at a lookout over Lake LaVista |
Of all the buildings on the lot, the jail was the least comfortable, by design. The Chamber's history says the 1927 cell was used to punish rowdy, drunken patrons. Its barred windows had no glass or screens, so whoever spent the night inside spent it with the mosquitoes. A fire in the 1940s damaged it, and what remains has no roof and no door. Even a burned jail cell was worth keeping.
The museum keeps shorter hours this time of year. Through December it is open 10 a.m. to 1 p.m., and it is closed Sundays and Mondays. Starting in January it stays open until 4 p.m. on the days it opens. The society's homepage carries the full seasonal schedule, so check it before planning around spring hours. The gift shop sells local art, books and apparel.
On a morning walk before the doors open, the jail and the Mangrove Walk are already open. For longer outings, the society offers free, self-guided walking-tour brochures for Anna Maria, Holmes Beach and Bradenton Beach. They are written to be followed on foot, by bike or from the trolley.
December puts the grounds at the center of Pine Avenue
For one evening last December, the lot at 402 Pine Ave. was the busiest part of the street. The Sun's coverage of the Dec. 12, 2025 Holiday of Treasures Open House describes an event hosted together by the Anna Maria business community, the City of Anna Maria and the Historical Society, with Pine Avenue closed to traffic.
The museum grounds held the city's Christmas tree, other lit trees and illuminated walkways. Santa visited with children outside the museum and counted down while city staff lit the tree at 6 p.m. Museum volunteers handed out free wine and popcorn, and the Parrish Community High String Quintet played Christmas music. Along the street, the Sun named Beach Bums, Pineapple Marketplace, Reclaimed Soul, Rock n' Eggroll, Anna Maria General Store, Two Scoops Ice Cream, Cool Beans AMI, Anna Maria Oyster Bar, Pizza Social, Flip Flop Shop & Candy Stop, The Chocolate Emporium and Donut Experiment among the participants. Mayor Mark Short said the event's return was a sign of recovery after the hurricanes the year before.
It made sense to light the city's tree on the grounds of a museum that had been flooded fifteen months earlier, next to a cottage that had just gotten new floors.
The same stretch of Pine Avenue has its own December tradition up the street. Roser Memorial Community Church, at 512 Pine Ave. near the City Pier, has scheduled its Bethlehem Walk for Sunday, Dec. 13, 2026. Participants gather in front of the sanctuary at 5:30 p.m. and set out at 6:00 p.m. on a one-block reenactment of Mary and Joseph's search for shelter, with a llama, donkeys and goats, singing carols as they go from "inn" to "inn." Costumes can be borrowed from the Narthex on a first-come, first-served basis, the church asks walkers to bring a flashlight, and cookies and drinks follow back at the church.
Belle Haven sits a short walk down the same street at 402 Pine Ave., open by docent-guided tour.
Many of the island's older cottages have been through their own storms, renovations and close calls, and the people who own them tend to know those histories well. If you have one of these homes, or hope to someday, and want to talk about what it takes to care for an older island property, Kathy Harman would be glad to hear from you. Discuss your island priorities, and let's find the perfect waterfront fit.