On Jan. 1, the rental cabanas on Anna Maria's beach go from an open field of operators to three franchised companies working under a hard ceiling. The headline number is 36 rental cabanas a day. For anyone who walks, swims or wakes up near the six blocks between Magnolia and Oak avenues, the number that matters more is six: the most rental setups any single block can hold on a given day. Add a 9 a.m. start that's already in force and a pickup deadline tied to sunset, and the city has built its cabana rules around the hours and the stretches of beach its residents complained about most.
The vote came at the Oct. 8 commission meeting. As the Anna Maria Island Sun reported, commissioners voted 4-0 to give two-year franchise agreements to Beach Suites, CabanUp and My Beach Concierge. Starting Jan. 1, those three will be the only companies allowed to offer cabana rental, setup and delivery in the city.
Every block now carries its own ceiling
The rental zone isn't getting bigger. It's still the six blocks running south from Magnolia Avenue to Oak Avenue. What's new is that the ordinance counts setups block by block, so no single block can fill up while the others stay empty.
Each franchisee gets a maximum of 12 rentals a day and no more than two in any one block. Three companies at two apiece works out to the six-per-block cap written into the ordinance.
| Block in the rental zone | Most rental setups per day | Most per company |
|---|---|---|
| Magnolia to Palm | 6 | 2 |
| Palm to Palmetto | 6 | 2 |
| Palmetto to Willow | 6 | 2 |
| Willow to Cedar | 6 | 2 |
| Cedar to Mangrove | 6 | 2 |
| Mangrove to Oak | 6 | 2 |
That table answers a specific complaint. At a January workshop, the AMI Sun reported, Mayor Short said, "We have pictures from the day after Christmas of five in a row and five in a row and I personally don't want to see that." The spacing rules that already applied are still in place. No more than two commercial rental areas can sit within 50 linear feet of each other in any direction, and beach access must stay clear at all times. With those rules and a six-per-block limit together, a long wall of rented shade in front of one stretch of homes no longer fits within the rules.
The ordinance also lets the commission change these numerical limits by resolution. The table reflects the rules taking effect Jan. 1, and the city has written in room to adjust them.
The clock was set by the people who live on the sand
The schedule took effect before the cap did. When commissioners revised the ordinance on Aug. 27, they moved the earliest setup time for rental cabanas from 7 a.m. to 9 a.m., starting the next day. The AMI Sun's September report explained the reason. Residents and beachfront property owners in and near the six blocks had asked for a mostly clear view of the beach during the first hours of daylight, and the later start also gives everyone time to set up their own shade before the shoreline fills.
According to the city's minutes, residents had complained about more than the view. Commissioners discussed commercial vehicles, backup alarms and setup activity cutting into residents' ability to enjoy their properties early in the day, and they described the 9 a.m. rule as a balance between that and commercial activity.
The rule held on its first big weekend. A Sun reporter walked the beach from Magnolia to Palm at 8:45 a.m. on Saturday, Sept. 5, during Labor Day weekend, and found one rental cabana up. By about 10 a.m., several more had been set up.
The end of the day is set the same way. Under the revisions the Sun reported, rental equipment has to be removed by 6 p.m. or one hour before sunset, whichever is earlier, with an allowance for removals delayed by bad weather. In the short days of winter, the sunset half of that rule kicks in first, so rental shade comes off the beach well before the evening walk. Each franchisee also has to keep a trash bag or receptacle at its rental area.
How a year of complaints became a franchise
The franchise system grew out of an enforcement question, which helps explain why it's built this way.
- July 2025. Mayor Mark Short told commissioners that existing code already barred commercial activity in the city's beach areas and that the rule wasn't being enforced. He framed the issue as commercial activity in general, not cabanas alone. The Sun covered the discussion as a choice between enforcing the old ban and creating a regulated option.
- January 2026. Workshops looked at how to balance rental service with public access, with the mayor's pictures of cabanas five in a row as one example.
- March 2026. The first commercial rental rules took effect and limited rentals to the six-block zone. The fine schedule the Sun reported at adoption ran from $100 for a first violation to $500 for a third, plus $50 for abandoned beach equipment.
- August 2026. Commissioners approved Ordinance 26-961 on first reading Aug. 13 and adopted it Aug. 27. It added the per-block caps, the 9 a.m. start and a limit of three franchises. The mayor tied the changes to resident and property-owner feedback about how much commercial activity there was, where it was concentrated, early setups and the effects on beachfront properties.
- October 2026. A city evaluation committee scored the three applications Oct. 1, and the commission awarded all three franchises Oct. 8.
The per-block cap only takes effect once the franchises are in place, which is why the 9 a.m. start has applied since late summer while the 36-cabana limit begins Jan. 1.
Personal shade and the beach
Chapter 38 includes general beach rules addressing temporary shade structures and personal property. Here are provisions from the city's January agenda packet and local reporting.
- Size. The ordinance text in the city's January agenda packet limits temporary shade structures on the beach to 169 square feet of total ground coverage and 13 linear feet, counting poles, pegs, tie-downs, anchors, weights and sandbags. Its definition covers a tent, umbrella, cabana, canopy or similar shelter.
- Dusk. The same text says, "All personal property must be removed from any Beach by dusk. Any property remaining after dusk is deemed abandoned." Officials can confiscate abandoned items when the owner can't be found, and unclaimed property can be disposed of after 90 days.
- Dunes. In March, the mayor discussed personal cabanas and tents in coastal-conservation beach areas and their placement seaward of the dune line, the Sun reported.
- Location. Commercial rentals stay banned in front of the Sandbar Seafood & Spirits and along the public beach out to and including Bean Point.
This is general information drawn from published city documents and local reporting, not legal advice. If a specific setup or property question is riding on the wording, check the city's current ordinance text or ask the city directly.
The two-year clock and the open fee question
The franchises run for two years, and the commission's own debate made clear the arrangement will be reviewed again. Commission Chair Charlie Salem backed awarding all three so each company could "prove whether or not they are going to be good stewards of this activity," with performance and compliance reviewed in two years, according to the Sun's account of the Oct. 8 meeting. Commissioner Kathy Morgan-Johnson said she didn't "want to have no cabanas on the beach," and she noted the two-year term gives the city time to measure its costs.
The fees are the unsettled part. My Beach Concierge will pay $15,000 a year, CabanUp $10,000 and Beach Suites $5,000. That's $30,000 a year to the city in monthly payments starting Jan. 1. City Treasurer Randy Maxson said the proposed fees would cover about half of the city's estimated enforcement and administrative costs. Commissioner John Lynch said his own analysis put the bids "significantly lower" than he thought they should be. City Attorney Pam Cichon questioned whether companies with the same rights should pay different amounts. Mayor Short explained that renegotiating the fees would require a new request for proposals, which would take at least six weeks.
Commissioner Chris Arendt, who was absent, sent a letter saying he would have voted for the top two bids. Under the ordinance, the next franchise application window will be Sept. 1 through Sept. 15 of the year the two-year cycle comes back around, with a committee appointed by the mayor scoring the applicants.
If your home, rental or favorite morning walk sits between Magnolia and Oak, the new block-by-block rules shape your stretch of sand more than any listing photo can. Kathy Harman follows these details closely for island owners. Discuss your island priorities, and let's find the waterfront fit that matches how you actually use the beach.